Skip to Main Content

Middle Grades Education: EDTD 6461 - Critical Issues in Middle/Secondary Education (Pettit)

EDTD 6461: Critical Issues in Middle/Secondary Education 

Course Mini Guide

EDTD 6461: Assignment 5 - Annotated Bibliography

 Compile an annotated bibliography on your chosen topic (different from those cited in your initial exploratory paper and different from those included in the modules).

Cite at least 3 high-quality scholarly articles (using APA) as well as two other sources of information such as videos, webinars, or websites. The highest grades will be given to those who explore more than one related topic (such as suicide and gun control) and have resources included for both on the bibliography.

To successfully complete the research component of this assignment there are 4 main steps:

  1. Develop a Search Strategy - plan your search before you begin searching (doesn't have to be detailed - but have a rough plan at least).
  2. Locate at least 5 scholarly sources, and at least 4 sources of other types for each topic (that way you have backup plans if a couple of them aren't useful).
  3. Skim through the scholarly articles and other sources and evaluate which ones to keep and which ones to discard. 
  4. Cite in-text and reference each source in APA Style. 

Where to go in this Research Guide for advice on Step...

Search GALILEO

GALILEO searches across all of the Libraries' databases at once.
Enter a few keywords and/or "key phrases", or search by title or author > Search or hit Enter/Return

DISCOVER articles, books, media, and more

Search GALILEO

Max your search strategy like a pro with search tactics and techniques - Example

The table below outlines search techniques to help you find more relevant results. Go to each tab to find out more about each one.

The examples given are for searching the following research question:  

Write an annotated bibliography on how teachers can help prevent substance abuse in middle schoolers
  1. Firstly, identify the key concepts: words or key phrases: 
    • teachers
    • prevent
    • substance abuse
    • middle schoolers

 

  1. Identify appropriate keywords or key phrases from your key concepts: Your keywords or key phrases might be the same words as your key concepts, or you might need to think of different words to use instead, better suited for a database search.
    • teachers - that is fine, let's keep that
    • prevent - that is fine, let's keep that
    • "substance abuse" - this is great, let's keep that
    • "middle schoolers" ... middle schoolers is informal. "Middle school" would be a more appropriate keyword and "middle schoolers" would be picked up anyway in a search on that keyword.

 

  1. Brainstorm any word variations, synonyms, or related concepts: Think of additional synonyms or related keywords to include in your search. For example:
  • teachers - educators
  • "substance abuse" - "drug abuse"
  • prevent - prevention, preventative
  • "middle school" - "middle grades"

 

  1. Apply the following search techniques wherever applicable to find more relevant results.
Search Technique
Format
Example
Exact Phrase Searching "key phrase"

"substance abuse"

Boolean Operators AND, OR, NOT

Search field 1: "substance abuse" OR "drug abuse"

Search field 2:  AND teachers OR educators

Search field 3: AND prevent

Search field 4: AND "middle school" OR "middle grades"

Parentheses

(keyword/phrase BOOLEAN OPERATOR keyword/phrase)

("substance abuse" OR "drug abuse") AND (teachers OR educators) AND prevent AND ("middle school" OR "middle grades")

Truncation Device

 

Typically an asterisk: *

May vary according to database

teach*

will retrieve

teach, teachers, teaching, etc.

Wildcard

Typically a pound: # , or a question mark: ?

Varies from database to database

GALILEO / EBSCOhost: #

Proquest: ?

In GALILEO and EBSCOhost databases

"STE#M education" 

will retrieve

"integrative STEM education", "integrative STEAM education", etc.

 

Exact Phrase Search

What it does The format Example/s

Will retrieve results containing your "key phrase" in the order that you have inputted at least once in the record details or the item contents

"Key phrase"

"middle school" will find the phrase 'middle school" at least once in the record or in the full-text. It won't separate the words.

 

Boolean Operators

What they do The format Example

Boolean operators are 'connectors'.

They combine keywords or key phrases in order to narrow or expand your search. 

In a simple search, if you use no Boolean Operator, the default operator is typically AND.

AND

OR

NOT

teach

AND prevent

AND "drug abuse" OR "substance abuse"

AND "middle school" OR "middle grades"

NOT "elementary school"

 

Wildcard

What it does The format Example

Wildcards broaden your search results by substituting or including a character in your keyword or key phrase.

There are 2 types of wildcards:

  • Substitutes the wildcard symbol for any character and includes the original word. Therefore, it finds all citations of the word that appear without the extra character

  • Substitutes the wildcard symbol for a character only

Great for including spelling variations of a keyword in your search.

Typically a pound, i.e. #,  exclamation mark, i.e. ! or question mark, i.e. ?

Varies according to the database.

Some databases may use both types of wildcards, some may only use one.

Consult the database's 'Help' or 'Search Tips' page to verify the wildcard symbol and what it does.

 GALILEO & EBSCOhost databases

 

"STE#M education" 

will retrieve

"STEM education" and "STEAM education"

 

 

 

 

Truncation

What it does The format Example - GALILEO and EBSCOhost databases

Enter part of a keyword and place the truncation symbol at the end. The database will return results that include any ending of that partial word.

Typically an asterisk i.e. *

May vary from database to database.

prevent*

will retrieve prevent, prevention, preventative, etc.

teach* 

will retrieve teach, teaching, etc.

***

Search field 1: "substance abuse" OR "drug abuse"

Search field 2:  AND teachOR educat*

Search field 3: AND prevent*

Search field 4: AND "middle school" OR "middle grades"

 

Parentheses

What they do The format Example/s

Parentheses direct the search engine to perform your search in a certain order.

When you edit / modify your search in some databases, it will convert your query into the parentheses structure.

If you understand the structure, you can edit your search quickly.


Example: 

(keyword/phrase BOOLEAN OPERATOR keyword/phrase)

BOOLEAN OPERATOR

(keyword/phrase BOOLEAN OPERATOR keyword/phrase

 

("substance abuse" OR"drug abuse") AND (teach* OR educat*) AND prevent* AND ("middle school" OR "middle grades")

Find articles in databases - a "medium level" search

Why search within an individual or a set of databases rather than GALILEO?

As GALILEO covers a wide range of disciplines, searching within an individual, or a small set of subject-specialty databases can be more on target and efficient. It is worth trying GALILEO first, and then run a similar search in a subject database/set of databases. 

Did you know EBSCOhost databases can be searched together?
Enter one of the EBSCOhost databases below> Select 'Choose Databases' > Select desired databases  > OK.

Did you know EBSCOhost databases can be searched together?
Enter one of the EBSCOhost databases below> Select 'Choose Databases' > Select desired databases  > OK.

Combining Multiple Search Techniques

FAQCan you combine multiple search techniques to save time?

It depends on the database. Some databases will allow you to construct a complex search query which utilizes several search techniques. Other databases 'can't handle' operating too many techniques.

The easiest way to tell is trial and error.

Start with a simple search, then gradually layer it with more and more search techniques to see how much the database can 'handle' at once. 

Example: GALILEO can handle complex search queries. Try it yourself:

Search Field 1: "substance abuse" OR "drug abuse"

Field 2: AND "middle school" OR "middle grades" 

Field 4: AND  "teach* strateg*" OR  "teach* interven*"

Field 5: NOT "elementary school" OR "high school"

However, another database might not be able to handle such a combination of search techniques.